Recent revelations about the troubled backgrounds of contestants on the reality TV show The Bachelor have shattered the illusions of viewers and participants alike, challenging the narrative that reality TV is a safe haven for finding love.
Efforts to Revive Viewership
Three years ago, The Bachelor faced declining ratings, with premieres attracting just 2–3 million viewers compared to the 10 million it once commanded. In 2023, ABC rejuvenated the franchise with The Golden Bachelor, featuring Gerry Turner, a 72-year-old widower searching for love. The premiere drew over 7 million viewers, including streaming, making it the most-watched debut since 2020.
However, the renewed honeymoon phase was short-lived. While the show traditionally promised romance through luxurious dates in idyllic settings, recent scandals have undermined this fantasy.
Tarnished Candidates
Before Turner could hand out his final rose, reports surfaced detailing his ambiguous job history and strained past relationships. His eventual marriage to Theresa Nist lasted only three months, further dampening fans’ enthusiasm.
In another instance, The Bachelorette‘s recent lead, Jenn Tran, faced public humiliation when her engagement ended abruptly. Devin Strader, her chosen partner, broke off the engagement via phone. On live television, Tran tearfully relived the proposal scene, prompting criticism from fans who felt the producers exploited her vulnerability for drama.
Adding to the backlash, a blogger revealed Strader’s 2017 felony conviction for breaking into an ex-girlfriend’s home. He pleaded guilty to criminal trespassing and damage under $500, resulting in probation. These revelations, coupled with declining viewership of The Golden Bachelorette, painted a grim picture for the franchise.
Lax Vetting Processes
The Bachelor has faced scrutiny over its background checks. In 2018, a contestant with a pending sexual assault case was cast, leading producers to promise stricter protocols. Despite these assurances, recent scandals highlight persistent flaws. For example, a contestant on The Golden Bachelorette faced allegations of stalking shortly before filming began.
Reality shows often prioritize drama over diligence, but stricter vetting is vital if The Bachelor wants to maintain credibility as a matchmaking platform. By ignoring these responsibilities, the show risks alienating both viewers and participants.
